No re-playability.

User Rating: 6.1 | Battlestations: Midway PC
Save your money. This game suffers from several major flaws: short campaign, no sandbox mode, no scenario editor, and very limited joystick compatibility (try going from Microsoft Flight Simulator X to flying with a mouse on this game). The graphics are nice, and the game could have really been something great. However, just plain ignorance of what makes a good game have sealed the coffin on this one. I give it a "2" for re-playability. Perhaps GameSpot should add a category for that, which might have brought the game down to about the 6.0 it deserved. Way overrated by the GameSpot team. The game had a lot of potential, but I played through the entire campaign in one afternoon and then wondered where my money went. For those naval war buffs out there, I suggest you stick to the Silent Hunter series.