Rate all Assassin's Creed games

#1 Posted by HipHopBeats (2907 posts) -

Favorite to least favorite

AC2 - 9.5

ACB - 9.0

AC3 - 8.5

AC1 - 8.0

ACR - 7.0

#2 Posted by OmenUK (3302 posts) -

Assassins Creed - 8.5
Assassins Creed 2 - 9.0
Assassins Creed Brotherhood - 8.5
Assassins Creed Revelations - 8.0
Assassins Creed 3 - N/A*

* Not played yet 

#3 Posted by LLYNCES (381 posts) -
* Not including AC III as haven't finished it yet or played any of the multiplayer. AC II 9.5 AC I: 9.0 (Rating it by the standards set back in 2007, though compared to every Assassins creed console game after it, it is worse) AC Brotherhood: 9.0 AC Revelations: 8.0 Currently AC III is leaning around the 9.0-9.5 for me right now.
#4 Posted by planetpisces (113 posts) -
AC2 - 9.0 ACB - 9.0 ACR - 8.5 AC1 - 8.5 AC3 - ?
#5 Posted by Cakolukia (245 posts) -

Am I the only one that LOVED Brotherhood??

 

Anyways:

AC:B - 10

AC:2 - 9.5

AC:R - 9.0

AC:1 - 8.0

AC:3 - This could potentially be my favorite of them all if it keeps up as it has to this point. The storyline and my feelings toward the characters are way beyond what they have been in the past (though the recent ending to AC:R came close).

#7 Posted by ogerseni168 (56 posts) -

AC2 - 9.5

ACB - 9.0

AC1 - 8.0

ACR - 8.0

AC Bloodlines (PSP) - 6.5

AC3 - Not sure yet, still playing seq 2 (so far, 8.0).

AC 3 Liberation (PS Vita) - Haven't played it yet.

#8 Posted by that_duuude (12 posts) -
AC2 - 9.5 *the story and new gameplay made this series AC3 - 9.2 *the gameplay improvements and scenery ACB - 8.8 *basically AC2 with minor improvements ACR - 8.4 AC1 - 8.2 Ezio will always be my favorite assassin. I love Connor's story but compared to Ezio, Connor isn't as likable. But it's just my opinion. I love all the games!!
#9 Posted by idunnodude (2282 posts) -

i guess im the only one that liked revelations the best. havent beat ac3 yet but i don't like it as much as ACB and ACR. mainly because i think connor is the most boring assassin ever. the guy has no personality. Ezio was way more awesome.

AC1:8

AC2:9

ACB:8.75

ACR:9

#10 Posted by darkfiercelink (117 posts) -

AC1- 8

AC2- 9

ACR- 8.5

AC3-9

#11 Posted by xwestsdeaznx (121 posts) -

AC1: 8.0

AC2: 9.5

ACB: 8.5

ACR: 8.5

AC3: So far, 9.0

#12 Posted by Slinqy (244 posts) -
AC1: 8.0 AC2: 9.0 ACB: 9.0 ACR: 8.5 AC3: 9.0
#13 Posted by Magnaxilorius (232 posts) -

Assassin's Creed - 8.5

Assassin's Creed II - 9.5

Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood - 8.5

Assassin's Creed: Revelations - 7.5

Assassin's Creed III - 9.0

#14 Posted by KevinConklin (1620 posts) -

Assassin's Creed - 8.5

Assassin's Creed II - 9.5

Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood - 8.5

Assassin's Creed: Revelations - 8.5

Assassin's Creed III - 9.0

#15 Posted by Minishdriveby (10033 posts) -
AC3 - 9.0 AC2 - 9.0 ACB - 7.5 ACR - 7.5 AC1 - 6.5
#16 Posted by JarOfGunz (368 posts) -

Assassin's Creed 2: 9.5
Assassin's Creed 3: 9.0
Assassin's Creed Brotherhood: 8.9
Assassin's Creed: 8.5
Assassin's Creed Revelations: 8.5

#17 Posted by Roanark (2467 posts) -
Assassin's Creed: 8.0 The game-play was new and exciting, story? Superb. Though it was very repetitive and the characters lacked any real depth. Assassin's Creed 2: 9.5 The ONLY reason it wasn't a ten for me is making two whole sequences of crucial story DLC, I mean really Ubisoft? Really? Everything was such a huge improvement, it's my favorite game of all time. Assassin's Creed Brotherhood: 8.5 Enjoyable, good story, some new mechanics... But it was by all means an expansion onto the second game that really could of been cheaper and made as a DLC. I know, people will get on me for saying that but it's just how it felt to me. Assassin's Creed Revelations: 7.0 This game was... Unspeakably terrible... There were not any stunning "Revelations" to be had. Desmond game-play was entirely option, did very little for the story, and was more a bother than anything else. I was rushing through it just to be finished. No new mechanics except the hookblade. MANY promises were left feeling unfulfilled. ....Coming from a devout fan of the series, it was a disappointment and almost had me giving up on the series. And, since I'm getting it for PC, I can not yet judge AC 3... I'm being hopeful, as this will probably be what decides if I ever buy another AC game again.
#18 Posted by inFAMOUSFan101 (2 posts) -

Assassins Creed                    7.5

Assassins Creed 2                 9.7

Assassins Creed Brotherhood 9.0

Assassins Creed Revelations  8.7

Assassins Creed 3                 8.2

#19 Posted by agroxx (1 posts) -
Assasins creed 2=9.0 Assasins creed brotherhood=8.5 Assasins creed=8.0 Assasins creed 3=7.5 Assasins creed revealations=5.0
#20 Posted by daredevil313 (11 posts) -

AC I = 10/10

AC II = 10/10

AC B = 8.5/10

AC R = 8/10

AC III = 8.5/10

#21 Posted by bladderworts (30 posts) -
Assassins Creed - 8.0 Assassins Creed 2 - 9.0 Assassins Creed 3 - 10.0
#22 Posted by Zekethompson22 (17 posts) -
AC 2 : 9.5 AC 3: 9.0 AC R: 8.5 AC B : 8.0 AC: 8.0
#23 Posted by DragonHuntress7 (126 posts) -

AC1 - 7

ACII - 9

ACB - 8.5

ACR - 8.0

ACIII - 7.5

#24 Posted by Black_Hand_313 (787 posts) -

Interesting, I was expecting more ACIII hate. My ratings:

 

ACII: 9.0 (best of the series)

 

ACIII: 8.5 (bugs and inconsistent story, but still have a soft spot for it)

 

AC Brotherhood: 8.5 (improved gameplay over ACII, but I didn't like the story)

 

ACI: 8.5 (repetitive but unique)

 

AC Revelations: 7.5 (OK but only had a few standout parts, I hated Den Defense)

#25 Posted by Street-killer86 (6 posts) -

AC1=6.5

AC2=9.0

ACB=8.5

ACR=8.0

AC3=10.0

AC4=not played yet.

#26 Posted by maityankit (24 posts) -
  • Assassin's Creed - 7.5
  • Assassin's Creed II - 8.5
  • Assassin's Creed Brotherhood - 10.0
  • Assassin's Creed Revelations - 8.0
  • Assassin's Creed III - 9.0
  • Assassin's Creed IV - 9.5
#27 Posted by Kevlar101 (6218 posts) -
  • Assassins Creed - 7/10
  • Assassins Creed II - 8/10
  • Assassins Creed: Brotherhood - 7/10
  • Assassins Creed: Revelations - 7/10
  • Assassins Creed III - 8/10
  • Assassins Creed IV: Black Flag - 9/10
#28 Posted by timbad (21 posts) -

I think I agree with the original poster, although I enjoyed Revelations more than a 7.0 ...perhaps a 7.8?

Haven't finished AC 3 yet, so can't really comment too well, but do agree with others that Connor is so boring.

Probably won't finish it for a while now, as I've got distracted by Watch Dogs!

#29 Edited by HoolifanStyle (39 posts) -
  • Assassins Creed - 8/10
  • Assassins Creed II - 9/10
  • Assassins Creed: Brotherhood - 9/10
  • Assassins Creed: Revelations - Don't have
  • Assassins Creed III - 8/10
  • Assassins Creed IV: Black Flag - need to finish AC3
#30 Posted by TUROK533 (6 posts) -

Rate Assassins Creed.....Well, here is my ratings...

AC One.....A good first effort..good story line....plenty of action...enjoyed the concept......7.5

AC Two.....Even better second effort...built on the first AC story line...improved action..impressed...8

AC Brotherhood......Now this is where it got interesting with the concept of a fraternity of Assassins.

I enjoyed finding potential Assassins, training, and etc, there was some thought put into a kind of ritual for eventual effort to becoming an Assassin....that really appealed to me..enjoyed it heaps..8.5

AC Revelations...Again, nice continuation to the Assassins Creed kudos....older, wiser, same concept with trainee assassins...Mmm...no ritual was a let down, however, thought went into new ideas with explosives, parachute...loved that.....and the Hook Blade...Damm! Loved everything about this new tool both in combat and loved the zip line!

Rated this one at 9

AC Three....mmmmm..Things started to go astray in this AC...Connor, at first, didn't have any real personality as the other main characters, but he did grow on me.

Story line was pretty good, better than average history lessons throughout the game. Characters pretty much told the truth about themselves.

Combat action was awesome, especially Connor's unarmed fisty cuffs! Once I worked out how to do this, I hardly used any weapons thoughout the game, although his wooden club was pretty awesome to watch in action too!

The wilderness hunting was pretty good and in character with his heritage, plus, you had to think in hunting different animal, enjoyed that.

The sea battles were a new concept and well presented and thought out, very realistic if you have ever been to sea before.

Rated this one 9

AC Black Flag......This AC is definitely the worst one of the lot! You guys who put this package together should hang your heads in shame! It's the most repetitive game I have ever played. It was so boring, lacklustre in every way imaginable, no real story line, sea battles exactly same through out ...and not !very good by the way, main character unliveable and a total waste of time and money.

The producers of this game got real lazy, they didn't bother enhancing the AC idea, didn't give anything new in weapons, lost the outstanding Hook Blade which would have been ideal in ship's rigging or zip lines through out the game...nah, that was all too hard for them to include in this poorly presented game......I got so fed up with this crap game, I threw it in the rubbish bin not finished! ........rate this 2!

After the last very poor attempt, I sure as s@#t ain't going to rush out a buy AC Unity till I see and hear it's worth buying!