Q&A: LucasArts VP Peter Hirschmann

Star Wars publisher's vice president of production talks about the now-done Day 1 deal and the joy of next-generation development.

by

Earlier today, LucasArts announced that it had entered into a partnership with Day 1 Studios to develop a new, unnamed next-generation console game. The developer made its mark in 2002 with MechAssault, one of the first games to take full advantage of Xbox Live. It released a sequel, MechAssault 2: Lone Wolf, in late 2004 and is currently working on the Xbox 360 port of F.E.A.R.

LucasArts, of course, is most famous for its myriad games based on properties from its sister company, Lucasfilm. However, it describes its collaboration with Day 1 as a "new next-generation entertainment franchise." Though some speculate that the game could be the rumored Darth Vader backstory game, it appears more likely that it will be set outside the Star Wars universe that has inspired the majority of LucasArts games.

Indeed, Day 1 president Denny Thorley told GameSpot that the deal with LucasArts was partially inspired by Mercenaries, LucasArts' non-Star Wars-related collaboration with Pandemic Studios. That game won widespread critical acclaim for its innovative gameplay; its success was also a factor in Pandemic's merger with similarly esteemed developer BioWare last year.

Thorley said that LucasArts' desire to create a similarly cutting-edge franchise for next-generation consoles was what made him want to work with the publisher. Such admiration was reciprocated by Peter Hirschmann, LucasArts' vice president of product development. The executive spoke with GameSpot about the deal and told us what he could about his company's top-secret project.

GameSpot: Why did you want to work with Day 1?

Peter Hirschmann: Well, why not? When you're a publisher, you meet hundreds of developers and teams. Sometimes their ideas are cool but you don't think they can execute. Sometimes they've got some really smart people on staff but their ideas are retreads of something else. You just always wait and wait and wait for that magic combination of people coming with some great ideas you can actually pull off. Day 1 fit the bill.

I remember when his original MechAssault shipped and that was the killer app for Xbox Live. I think a lot of people forget, now that Live is such a success, that if it had gotten off on the wrong foot...well, who knows what would have happened. But I still remember reading about the penny arcade guys going crazy about playing MechAssault online.

So I was a fan of Day 1's product, and we had some people here who had worked over there before moving to California and really spoke highly of them. It came down to a meeting at E3 in 2005 where they came in and presented a whole bunch of stuff. They were just so wound up and so crackerjack that you couldn't help but be really impressed.

GS: How far along in development is this game that you can't name?

PH: We are up and running on [a] next-gen [console SDK]. It's playable, it's fun, and that's the telltale sign of a game. If it's fun to play even in its earliest prototype stages, you know that you're in for a wild ride. The various builds we've gotten over the last few months, I mean, people just sit around and play them and goof around and have fun with them. It's something that's truly unique, new, and different. That was the key thing for us. It definitely is a next-gen experience. It's not just a current-gen experience revved up--it's something that you can only do on next-gen.

GS: Do you think the only way to push the industry into the next era of gameplay is to do stuff you couldn't do before?

PH: Look, God bless anyone who shipped a title with the 360 launch and who's gearing up to do the same thing with the PlayStation 3. I mean, getting a game done is hard enough under the best circumstances, and to finish a game on hardware that's evolving is even worse. We went through it at LucasArts with Rogue Squadron II for the GameCube launch. It's incredibly tough.

So if some of the 360 and PS3 games were, arguably, just souped-up current-gen [games], that's because of the production obstacles those guys were up against. Now they've got great traction going into their next titles cause they've already gotten their feet wet. So I think it's real easy for people to sit back and go, "Aw, that was just a current-gen game, I'm not impressed." Well, you know, you want to try making it yourself?

So I think it's part of any natural hardware cycle. You'll see with the second and third wave you'll start seeing stuff that truly takes advantage of the hardware. These new machines are deep enough and complex enough that I think you're going to see a longer period of new things rolling out. I think it's going to be a few years until we come close to maximizing what these machines can do, just because they can do so much.

GS: It sounds like it's a pretty technology-driven project.

PH: Well, one of my favorite George Lucas quotes is, "A special effect by itself is a boring thing. A special effect with a story is potentially something truly special." Technology by itself is a waste of time, right? What got me hooked first was the idea for the game. You have people who have great ideas but can't pull it off and vice versa. They had the great idea, and then they came in and gave us a prototype. After seeing it, I was like, "OK, you guys can do this."

I don't mean to be vague about it, but we want to show it off in full glory when the time is right. But we are a technology-driven form of entertainment, and the key thing is they're building technology and tools that's going to help their designers and their artists. It's not just tech for tech's sake. It's actually something that affects gameplay. It affects how the game is designed and how the game is experienced. I think it's an action game and...not a puzzle game. I'll put it that way.

GS: Now Denny told us that one of the reasons he wanted to work with LucasArts is that your smaller release slate would provide for more support for this game.

PH: LucasArts is always only going to publish a certain number of titles a year. We want each one of them to be a home run and something that truly is next-gen. That was one of the biggest criteria, because if it was a really great idea but it could be executed on current-gen, well maybe we're not the right home for it. That was the package deal.

GS: Did they shop the project around to other publishers before they came to you?

PH: As far as I know, this was an idea that they came to us with first. I hope I didn't come on too strong with them! When I first met them at E3, I was really so impressed with them as people and the way they handled themselves and the materials they were presenting. At E3, they weren't pitching us the game. They were pitching themselves as a company, saying, "Here's our tools pipeline. Here's how we're organized. This is our past portfolio." I knew from that moment, man, we really want to work with these guys.

Over the next couple of months, the idea for this game came into form, and we talked about it and it developed into what it is now. So, I think it's fair to say that while we worked together exclusively on developing the game, it's their drive. Creatively, it's their great idea. I want to give them all the credit.

GS: You say you wanted to make a game that would be possible only on a next-gen platform. I was trying to wrap my head around what that could entail. Is there anything specific you can talk about?

PH: I can neither confirm nor deny any and specific features or feature set of the product.

GS: OK. I know LucasArts is tied into other mediums. Is there any chance we could see this property spread into maybe film or something else?

PH: You never know. Right now we're focused on coming up with the best ideas for games. I think if the game we wanted to live in the best gaming experience possible and if it makes sense for it to manifest itself in other forms of media, heck, yeah, we're on board with that. But we're focused on delivering the best next-generation game experience possible.

GS: How do you guys keep your mouth shut about all these things you're so excited about?

PH: That's a great question. I mean, we deal with some incredibly sensitive IP. I saw Star Wars: Episode III a year before it came out. So it's part of the culture here. Our IP is one of our most valuable assets, and if you spill the beans about a movie or game, it really robs it of its potency. Everyone loves the instant rush of a spoiler on the Internet. Then, after you read it, it's like, "Oh, I wish I hadn't seen that. I wish I had seen how that played out in a theater or in a game."

So I think it's traditionally, it's very important to maintain an integrity about what we're working on because, like I said, there's stuff in the pipe that I can't wait to talk about. But it's not the right time for a variety of reasons. You know, there's stuff going on with Star Wars that is really cool and exciting, but, you know, again, there's a time and place to talk about it.

Culturally, at LucasArts, I mean, we share a lot of information with Lucasfilm. Our new people are always surprised how much detail we go into at our company meetings, but it sort of says, "Hey, we trust you as a Lucasfilm employee. You're going to be exposed to a lot of really rockin' stuff and you got to keep it under your hat because that's part of the job." And I think everyone here then signs up for it.

Discussion

36 comments
REVENGEotSITH
REVENGEotSITH

What the heck happened to my comments? They weren't offensive, inflamatory, or anything like that. Nice one, Gamespot. You let people comment on what you post on your site - as long as it doesn't question what you wrote. All I asked was - what did this very lengthy article tell us gamers? Absolutely nothing. So Day 1 and LA are partnering. Companies partner all the time on projects. If there were ANY info regarding the game, the IP, the console, etc. - then that would be news to us. Nice job with the sensorship, GS.

_Sam_
_Sam_

Very interesting...

Psiphor
Psiphor

Over on http://www.cubed3.com/news/5681, they quote this developer (Day 1) as saying: “We’ve just signed non-disclosures with Nintendo. We’re going to be looking at their hardware very carefully. We’re not doing Mech games, but there’s lots of opportunity there for creative stuff.” So, there's a good chance Lucasarts are gonna be up for the Wii, what with their apparent enthusiasm for Day 1's team above. Anyone for lightsabers on Wii? Of course you are... Come on Lucasarts... You know it makes sense.

rawpower
rawpower

"Well, you know, you want to try making it yourself?" I'm sorry but that guy just sounds like an a**hole. Hopefully the ppl really in charge of making the game arent all like that.

Goombaloo
Goombaloo

"But we are a technology-driven form of entertainment and the key thing is they're building technology and tools that's going to help their designers and their artists. It's not just tech for tech sake. It's actually something that affects gameplay. It affects how the game is designed and how the game is experienced." See everyone, it's gonna be for the Wii........!

Total-KO
Total-KO

World Wrestling Everything is #1 Union On Gamespot!

SWANN2099
SWANN2099

Your crazy, man. KOTOR was tight!!! in every since of the word. Though I do agree with you that it could be another Jedi Knight's tale, a new KOTOR would be on point, especially if it's on the PS3 this time along with the Xbox 360.

Im_JUst_HERe
Im_JUst_HERe

its most likely going to be a next gen star wars game since there is already a kind of trailer out for it.. im guessing it will have very similar gameplay to the Jedi Knight series, seeing as those were some amazing games. it may also be another KotOR but i hope not, because RPGs just arent as fun as FPS or using a lightsaber your self to slice the arm of a storm trooper...

REVENGEotSITH
REVENGEotSITH

[This message was deleted at the request of a moderator or administrator]

REVENGEotSITH
REVENGEotSITH

[This message was deleted at the request of a moderator or administrator]

Flan_Man
Flan_Man

What, no snow-speeder using a tow-cable to trip up an AT-AT? GREAT! I like the sound of new.

cann0n2o
cann0n2o

I cant beleive he used the words "wild ride" its prob going to be some AT AT mech game based on star wars... AT-ST Commander or something like that... Lucasarts used to be a great company i really hope this is not another star wars game.

AfterAscon
AfterAscon

Glad they are doing something NEW rather than continuously drain the star wars license of life. Whatever it is, it's seems to be shaping up to be an amazing game.

ewjim
ewjim

On what platform it'l be? If they can play in it already I think it's TOO LITTLE information for us all... I don't like it...

lordseer
lordseer

Mechassault rocked hard. CTF in Mechassault was one of the deepest game modes ever in my opinion and remains my favorite game. DAY 1 + Lucas have the ability to do some great things together.

Spectre-123
Spectre-123

Yes, a new game (release it for PC as well please!!!). Hopefully a sequel to the KotOR series or Republic Commando would be sweet as.

IROCNV35
IROCNV35

A new Galaxies for the 360 would be off the chain ...if they make it like it was when galaxies 1st launched.....

beaudman
beaudman

I really like this Peter Hirschmann guy. His interview was refreshing next to some of the boring to death interviews with other companies.

Poedon
Poedon

I'd say god of war was an action/puzzle game. Imagine stomping around as Darth Vader slashing people up like Kratos!

NightZephyr
NightZephyr

It obviously an xbox 360 title considering what he says about not wanting to be dealing with making a game for a system before you have final hardware for a while, and making a launch or launch window game - and yet the game is already in playable form and running well. Well, ps3 final dev kits havent been out that long and neither have Wii's. Sounds like the 360 hardware is the only harware they could have had for a time long enough to fit in with everytng else he says. ok, so maybe its not OBVIOUSLY 360 - but it seems there are strong indications from what else he sais that is probably is... GO 360!!!

Kempatsu_basic
Kempatsu_basic

intereting. the vp is verydown to earth and knows his stuff. good luck!!

Donkeljohn
Donkeljohn

A puzzle game and an action game. . . Sounds alot like what Final Fantasy delivers, but in a solid RPG form.

assassinX01
assassinX01

loooong. I'm not sure how mercenaries can inspire an action/puzzle game, but they've got my attention.

smiley17O
smiley17O

second news for lucas arts today

blackIceJoe
blackIceJoe

Well that was a good read. I wonder what it really could be if Gamespot was wondering if there could be a movie about it. That would have been awesome to see Star Wars a year before it came out. Well its great to see the game only going on Next gen systems that way they can use what is in them more then having to water it down to work with the other systems game.

GTJimmy
GTJimmy

[This message was deleted at the request of a moderator or administrator]

1vgfan
1vgfan

hmm, still not that much info......3rd!

ronaldmonster
ronaldmonster

Look fact is me and millions of others want only one thing from you people now, KOTOR DAMN YOU WE WANT KOTOR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

XNbuck
XNbuck

hmmm... i don't feel any cooler.

XNbuck
XNbuck

[This message was deleted at the request of a moderator or administrator]