Oblivion nabs Spike TV top honors

Cliffy B, Gears also snare awards, but crowd reacts in disbelief as run-and-gun title for the 360 misses top prize.

by

LOS ANGELES--Another Spike TV Video Game Awards show, another star-studded event that might not have appealed to hardcore fans of the subject it's supposed to celebrate. However, in its fourth try, the "First Network for Men" did pull off one of its best awards shows, in terms of both production and worthy nominees.

Fiddy, Tyrese, and Jackson hang before the event.

The fourth annual Spike TV Video Game Awards were held at the Galen Center in Los Angeles Friday night, with veteran actor Samuel L. Jackson returning for the second consecutive year as the show's host.

The broadcast of Friday's event will be aired on the self-proclaimed "First Network for Men" next Wednesday at 10 p.m. ET/PT and will feature musical performances from Tenacious D and AFI. But GameSpot was in attendance this eve, with the results of the judges' voting below.

Team Gears of War, including Cliffy B (left), took home four awards.

The big winner of the night was The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, which scooped up five awards including the coveted Game of the Year prize. It wasn't a runaway victory for the Bethesda Softworks-developed game, though. Gears of War was neck-and-neck with Oblivion until the very last award--Game of the Year.

As the announcer listed off the nominees for Game of the Year, the greatest applause was aimed at Gears of War and Guitar Hero 2. But when Oblivion was announced as the winner, many in the crowd sounded stunned.

Oblivion also walked home with Most Addictive Game (voted on by the public), Best Performance by a Human (Male) for Patrick Stewart, Best Role-Playing Game, and Best Original Score. Gears of War took home four awards total, including Best Shooter, Best Graphics, Best Multiplayer Game, and Best Studio for its developers, Epic Games.

Tony Hawk's Project 8 won Best Individual Sports Game.

The Critics' Choice Award, the only category open for games released after November 7 (games scheduled for release before the end of the year were eligible for the Critics' Choice Award), went to The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess. By its requirements, the category was also the only chance for Wii or PlayStation 3 games to take home an award.

Tenacious D kicked off the ceremonies with the band's usual heavy-metal parody rock stylings, and Jackson continued the action with a few sketches before taking the stage in person. Helping Jackson out was Seth MacFarlane, bantering with the Snakes on a Plane star as the voice of Stewie Griffin from Family Guy. Presumably, Stewie will be animated in for the Wednesday broadcast.

There were some world-exclusive premieres, including footage of Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter 2, TNA Wrestling, and the opening cinematic from The Burning Crusade expansion of World of Warcraft. WOW got the deluxe treatment, with a congregation of robed, lip-synching figures taking the stage while the trailer showed above them, occasionally accompanied by some light pyrotechnics.

Heroes' Hayden Panettiere charmed the red carpet before presenting Most Addictive Game to Oblivion.

Beyond that, most of the presenters were in good spirits as they delivered their hit-and-miss lines before an oft-indifferent crowd. Former Dallas Cowboy Michael Irvin let go of a Wii Remote three times on the backswing of a Wii Sports golf game in a staged event, Masi Oka of Heroes dissed the WNBA when presenting the Best Team Sports Game Award, and Tyrese used the opportunity to promote his upcoming CD in the only ad-lib of the night.

The highlight of the evening came when comedienne Sarah Silverman brought her usual shtick of sarcastic humor to the stage, which was unfortunately lost on most of those in the crowd. She went on a tirade against gamers, saying they "should get an award for their work in AIDS prevention" because they simply stand no chance of getting laid.

Thankfully for those in attendance, Silverman's remarks apparently didn't apply to them. The MTV-generation audience continually filed out of the auditorium throughout the night muttering, "I don't even play video games."

The results of the 2006 Spike TV Video Game Awards are as follows (winners in bold):

GAME OF THE YEAR
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Bethesda)
Okami (Capcom/Clover Studio)
Gears of War (Microsoft/Epic Games)
Guitar Hero 2 (Red Octane/Harmonix)
Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter (Ubisoft)

CRITIC'S CHOICE
(game to be released after 11/15/2006 but before 12/31/2006)
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess (Nintendo/Nintendo EAD)
Resistance: Fall of Man (Sony Computer Entertainment America/Insomniac Games)
Medieval II: Total War (Sega/Creative Assembly)
Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six: Vegas (Ubisoft Montreal)
Wii Sports (Nintendo)

BEST DRIVING GAME
Burnout Revenge, Xbox 360 (Electronic Arts/Criterion Games)
Need For Speed Carbon (Electronic Arts/EA Black Box)
TOCA Race Driver 3 (Codemasters)
GTR 2 (10tacle Studios/SimBin Development Team)

BEST INDIVIDUAL SPORTS GAME
Rockstar Games Presents Table Tennis (Rockstar Games/Rockstar San Diego)
EA Sports Fight Night Round 3 (Electronic Arts/ EA Chicago)
Tony Hawk's Project 8 (Activision/Neversoft )
Tiger Woods PGA Tour 07 (Electronic Arts/EA Redwood Shores)
Top Spin 2 (2K Sports/Power and Magic)

BEST ACTION GAME
Dead Rising (Capcom)
New Super Mario Bros (Nintendo/Nintendo EAD)
Okami (Capcom/Clover Studio)
Saints Row (THQ/Volition)
Bully (Rockstar Games/Rockstar Vancouver)

BEST TEAM SPORTS GAME
NBA2K7 (2K Sports/Visual Concepts)
Madden NFL 07 (Electronic Arts/Tiburon)
NCAA Football 07 (Electronic Arts/Tiburon)
FIFA 07 (Electronic Arts/EA Canada)
NHL 07 (Electronic Arts/EA Canada)

CYBER VIXEN OF THE YEAR
Lara Croft - Tomb Raider: Legend (Eidos Interactive/Crystal Dynamics)
Alyx Vance - Half-Life 2: Episode 1 (Valve)
Princess Peach - New Super Mario Bros. (Nintendo/Nintendo EAD)
Enrica - Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Double Agent (Ubisoft Montreal)
Jen - Prey (2K Games/ Human Head Studios/3D Realms)

BEST SONG
"LocoRoco No Uta" by Nobuyuki Shimizu and Kemmei Adachi, LocoRoco (Sony Computer Entertainment America/SCE Studios Japan)
"Heavenly Star" by Genki Rockets, Lumines II (Buena Vista Games/Q Entertainment)
"Helicopter" by Bloc Party, Marc Ecko's Getting Up: Contents Under Pressure (Atari/The Collective)
"Summer Shudder" by AFI in Madden NFL 07 (Electronic Arts/Tiburon)
"Lights and Sounds" by YellowCard, Burnout Revenge-XBOX 360 (Electronic Arts/Criterion Games)

BEST SOUNDTRACK
Guitar Hero 2 (Red Octane/Harmonix)
Madden NFL 07 (Electronic Arts/Tiburon)
Scarface: The World is Yours (Vivendi/Radical Entertainment)
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories (Rockstar Games/Rockstar Leeds / Rockstar North)

STUDIO OF THE YEAR
Clover Studio (Okami)
Relic (Company of Heroes)
Cliff Bleszinski /Epic Games (Gears of War)
Todd Howard / Bethesda Softworks (The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion)
Harmonix (Guitar Hero 2)

BEST ORIGINAL SCORE
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Bethesda Softworks)
Bully (Rockstar Games/Rockstar Vancouver)
Electroplankton (Nintendo)
Okami (Capcom/Clover Studio)
Final Fantasy XII (Square Enix)

BEST FIGHTING GAME
Tekken: Dark Resurrection (Namco Bandai)
Dead or Alive 4 (Tecmo/Team Ninja)
Mortal Kombat Armageddon (Midway Games)
Street Fighter Alpha Anthology (Capcom)
God Hand (Capcom/Clover Studio)

BEST SHOOTER
Black (Electronic Arts/Criterion)
Prey (2K Games/ Human Head Studios/3D Realms)
Half-Life 2: Episode 1 (Valve)
Gears of War (Microsoft/Epic Games)
Call of Duty 3 (Activision/Treyarch)

BEST MILITARY GAME
Company of Heroes (THQ/Relic)
Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter (Ubisoft)
Call of Duty 3 (Activision/Treyarch)
The Outfit (THQ/Relic)
Battlefield 2142 (Electronic Arts/EA UK/DICE UK)

BEST GRAPHICS
Gears of War (Microsoft/Epic Games)
Okami (Capcom/Clover Studio)
Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter (Ubisoft)
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Bethesda Softworks)
Company of Heroes (THQ/Relic)

BEST HANDHELD GAME
New Super Mario (Nintendo/Nintendo EAD)
Brain Age: Train Your Brain in Minutes a Day (Nintendo)
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories (Rockstar Games/Rockstar Leeds/Rockstar North)
Tetris DS (Nintendo)
LocoRoco (Sony Computer Entertainment America/SCE Studios Japan)

BEST WIRELESS GAME
Diner Dash (Glu Mobile)
SWAT Force (Vivendi/KAOLink)
Tower Bloxx (Digital Chocolate)
Super K.O. Boxing (Glu Mobile)

BEST MULTI-PLAYER GAME
Gears of War (Microsoft/Epic Games)
Company of Heroes (THQ/Relic)
Metal Gear Solid 3: Subsistence (Konami/Kojima Productions)
Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter (Ubisoft)
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Double Agent (Ubisoft Montreal)

BREAKTHROUGH TECHNOLOGY
Wii (Nintendo)
PS3 (Sony Computer Entertainment America)
DS Lite (Nintendo)
Electroplankton (Nintendo)

BEST PC GAME
Company of Heroes (THQ/Relic)
Half-Life 2: Episode 1 (Valve)
Battlefield 2142 (Electronic Arts/Digital Illusions CE)
Star Wars: Empire at War (LucasArts/Petroglyph)
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Bethesda)

BEST RPG
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Bethesda)
Final Fantasy XII (Square Enix)
Kingdom Hearts II (Square Enix)
Valkyrie Profile 2: Silmeria (Square Enix/tri-Ace)

BEST GAME BASED ON A MOVIE OR TV SHOW
Lego Star Wars II: The Original Trilogy (LucasArts/Traveller's Tales)
The Godfather (Electronic Arts/EA Redwood Shores)
Scarface: The World is Yours (Vivendi/Radical Entertainment)
The Sopranos: Road to Respect (THQ/7 Studios)
Family Guy (2K Games/High Voltage Software)

BEST PERFORMANCE BY A HUMAN (MALE)
Seth MacFarlane in Family Guy (2K Games/High Voltage Software)
Gerry Rosenthal in Bully (Rockstar Games/Rockstar Vancouver)
Patrick Stewart in The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Bethesda Softworks)
Johnny Depp in Pirates of the Caribbean: The Legend of Jack Sparrow (Bethesda Softworks/7 Studios/Buena Vista Games)
Kiefer Sutherland in 24: The Game (2K Games/SCEE Studios Cambridge)

BEST SUPPORTING MALE PERFORMANCE
Seth Green in Family Guy (2K Games/High Voltage Software)
James Woods in Scarface: The World is Yours (Vivendi/Radical Entertainment)
James Caan in The Godfather (Electronic Arts/EA Redwood Shores)
Philip Michael Thomas in Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories (Rockstar Games/Rockstar Leeds/Rockstar North)
James Gandolfini in The Sopranos: Road to Respect (THQ/7 Studios)

BEST PERFORMANCE BY A HUMAN (FEMALE)
Vida Guerra in Scarface: The World is Yours (Vivendi/Radical Entertainment)
Tia Carrere in Saints Row (THQ/Volition)
Emmanuelle Vaugier in Need For Speed Carbon (Electronic Arts/EA Black Box)
Keely Haws in Tomb Raider: Legend (Eidos Interactive/Crystal Dynamics)
Rosario Dawson in Marc Ecko's Getting Up: Contents Under Pressure (Atari/The Collective)

BEST SUPPORTING FEMALE PERFORMANCE
Rachel Leigh Cook in Kingdom Hearts II (Square Enix)
Elisha Cuthbert in 24: The Game (2K Games/SCE Studios Cambridge)
Brittany Murphy in Marc Ecko's Getting Up: Contents Under Pressure (Atari/The Collective)
Mila Kunis in Family Guy (2K Games/High Voltage Software)
Lynda Carter in The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Bethesda)

BEST CAST IN A GAME
The Godfather (Electronic Arts/EA Redwood Shores)
Family Guy (2K Games/High Voltage Software)
Scarface: The World is Yours (Vivendi/Radical Entertainment)
Saints Row (THQ/Volition)
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Bethesda)

MOST ADDICTIVE GAME
The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion (Bethesda)
Brain Age: Train Your Brain in Minutes a Day (Nintendo)
Gears of War (Microsoft/Epic Games)
Guitar Hero 2 (Red Octane/Harmonix)
Company of Heroes (THQ/Relic)

Discussion

863 comments
chaudhrycurren
chaudhrycurren

This Game has just been leaked online, Play it at Newgame9.com

KittyKatLaura12
KittyKatLaura12

Most addictive game? The Elite Beat Agents would like to have a word with you. As much as I love rpgs, I never considered them addictive. And I would never imagine how any game could beat Okami for best graphics, even though Gears of War had great photorealistic graphics, I don't think they're half as beautiful. Although, I guess graphics and artwork are a completely different thing. One more comment... how did Brain Age and Tetris get on the list for best handheld game? XD

linkme
linkme

Gears of war and Oblivion are top games but some other games that deserve to be their are not there

blancobo
blancobo

Not a big fan on RPG;s dominating the face of mdern gaming. THough beautifully looking, they are too slow. Shooters on the other hand are very detailed but lack the "control" feeling from 3rd person games where obstacles, traps, and other elements can be added to improve the gaming experience.

VFG
VFG

It was nice to see that the awards weren't fixed this year and the show turned out better then the commercial it was last year.

Luigino_mp
Luigino_mp

I gotta agree with some of you guys. The pop people really need to stay away from anything that has the word "game" in it, but far as Oblivion and Gears of War go, I have to agree with them. Both are awesome games in their own respects. Gears of War got me addicted (which was a total shocker to me when I realized I had been playing the game for 11 hours straight, never happened before in all my years of playing video games. That Lancer RULES!!!). Oblivion's got the lead for me, though. It gets you more involved with the character, which is the ultimate seller. Just imagine every game that you love, and it doesn't matter what platform it is, or what game it is: You love the main character(s) in it. That's the way it is, and that's the way it's always gonna be. GoW has awesome gameplay that makes you want more, but that can only last for so long if you don't have a good enough character you can cling to loyally. (All you Halo games out there know what I'm talking about). ALL HAIL MASTER CHEIF!!!

DingoPinoy
DingoPinoy

I wish the gen pop would stop equating the video gaming population to the hip-hop crowd. I mean video gamers are diverse ... sure some are hip-hoppers, some are geeks (yours truly), some are sports fans , etc...

Radiozo
Radiozo

Correct vinner. Oblivion is the game Ive spent most time with this year. Strange that Final Fantasy XII wasnt nominated for best game tho. Its excellent. Gears of War is good but overrated. I got bored with it within a week. There is no replay value whatsoever.

HumanoMexicano
HumanoMexicano

Game, game, and game. That is all I say about this... if you do entertainment, do that. Don't mess with a world that doesn't belong to you. Leave it to real gamers. Oblivion is like how old now... and it got GOTY? The expansion pack itself got that? WTF? Well I have to say these awards mean nothing but whatever, war.(yes war)

ZMasterX
ZMasterX

Oblivion deserved to win, but on the other hand so did Gears of War. All of the games and the consoles that were picked were all good too. Next year the console wars will be on once more for the next gen gaming systems.

EnozmeH
EnozmeH

Wow... i completely avoided watching the awards show this year thinking that it was going to be a huge waste of time... no worries... they'll probably show it a hundred times in replays... Gears of war... LOST??? Whatever... hopefully they build upon the success they made this year and video gaming catches more attention... not that they need it... Next year.. with the next-gen consoles... it shud be crazy :lol:

jedi1977
jedi1977

I'm glad Oblivion won GOTY. It has more "meat" to it than Gears. I love shooters I play them all, but after all it was all said an done I was disappointed in Gears. Shallow play mechanics and repetitive game play. I haven't played it online yet, but the single player falls flat. I played for 5hrs on release date and haven't touched it since. Why do you ask did I play it for that long if I was disappointed? I was hoping it would get better than it was. Maybe it's because I need compelling characters and an awesome story...Gears had none of these. It could have but nope lets spend time and money on the looks of the game. I'll pick it up again soon and maybe I'll change my mind or maybe I won't. Both are great games but the better man won.

artiebillymac
artiebillymac

50 cent he sucks big time like his video game,we knew most winners but some game sucked that are some of the choices this is a huge gap from celebrities to real gamers. real gamers know more then this hollywood crap style awards

-Wildweasel-
-Wildweasel-

This is a good attempt at making gaming more mainstream. One problem, they are not in touch with gamers. They have no clue how diverse a community we are. All they know is what thier BS public relations people tell them. A few ideas on how they could improve this for next year. 1. Get Gamespot and other well respected gaming sites involved in selection and voting. 2. Dont give gamers people they dont want to see, SLJ is cool, but really, what does he have to do with gaming??? I would much rather see Valves pres up there. 3. Dont try so dayum hard! Okay, movies have the academy awards. The academy is made up of film critics, actors, directors, producers, etc. People INVOLVED with the industry. They vote on the nominees. As well as the awards. I dont like the idea of anyone other than the users of said materiel to vote on its impact, so in my plan, the "game academy" would choose the nominees, the users (US) would vote on it. Second, Get people involved in games as the people who present awards. Actors that actually work in games, well known game testers, hell, even pro gamers like u know who. Lastly, Spike, dont try so hard. There is beauty in simplicity and horror in things that are too complex. Stick to the old addage. KISS. Just my $00.05 you can take it or leave it, but rest assured, I will not be tuning in or paying any attention to the spike awards until its is a true representative of the gaming community. And last.....just wth is the "gaming lifestyle"??????? WW

psgored21
psgored21

i almost forgot, they got the best team sports game right....ea should be ashamed, in a genre where they had an 80% chance of winning....MAKE BETTER GAMES OR GIVE BACK THE LICENSES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

psgored21
psgored21

this award show on a production level was a piece of unicorn **** it looked like someone that had no idea about games whar so ever decides to make the show off of the general perception of gamers by the gen pop. this is the first one that i watched and from the opening sequence i thought something was up....i will watch again to see if they do it any justice and if they dont, this will end up being an easily overlooked and deservedly so award show for me, like the latin grammies..... most bs goes to family guy winning any awards and mka beat doa4, gtfoh..... oblivion deserved it, geow should of gotten most addictive because anyone who has played oblivion knows they have to be commited to damn near 200+ hrs from the jump...with GeOW the story wasnt all there but i can tell u that ive beaten the game 7x now, taking different strategies thru different parts with DIFFERENT people...how many 360 games are there that having xbl actually hurt it? now consider the inverse....when i think if addiction i think of it as a group activity...but thats my opinion...

teknocack
teknocack

Wow. Gotta worship people who compare a 3rd person shooter to a 3rd/1st person role-playing game. You people are my new gods. Yay to all the winners!!

kbblaze
kbblaze

What a Joke of all the fighting games MK A beats Tekken and DOA4 I know that onething is that it was a shock to many people and of all game to win,I mean the game itself does not have any ends which makes It WWWAAAKKK WAK anyways the reason I feel tekken and Doa were rip off is that Mka is Too UNREALLY ,THE FIGHTING DOESNT FLOW (IT FAST BUT IT FEELS LIKE DOING THE ROBOT DANCE). and its a game many people dont play compared to tekken it does not come close in terms of popularity (I know this geting carried away but if i ask a chick if they know MKA they wouldnt have a clue what your talking about but with tekken they would know cause there is no arcade centre with out at lest a tekken comepared to mka )

lithus
lithus

It shouldn't be THAT big of a surprise. Gears of War hasn't been out all that long, especially considering the prep time that goes into the VGA. GoW is actually lucky to have made the bill. Despite some clunky gameplay and numerous glitches, Oblivion is as beautiful as it is huge. It's had ample time to prove itself.

fahad2mail
fahad2mail

Elder scroll 4 obvilion and company of heros.

Angel113087
Angel113087

That's Bull**** gears of war was so much better than oblivion.

ballashotcalla1
ballashotcalla1

i love GoW but the only reason people think it shouldve won GotY is Bcuz it just came out.if GoW came out when oblivion did and oblivion came out when GoW did every1 would want oblivion 2 win and GoW would be collecting dust on the shelf.

CasSpy
CasSpy

Spike needs to get gamers to place what games should be in the catergories or something and then let us vote on them. cause spike is good at putting CSI on for 4 hours straight and causing a mass suicide rate from it. GoW is a much better game then Oblivion, why you ask?? cause its not a game you would put down to take a break from. GoW gets turned off cause you have to eat, sleep, or go to work. Oblivion gets put down cause they made a game about the size of the earth and made it single player. Don't get me wrong its a GREAT game but let me check my drawer and see whats collecting dust right now...... Oblivion, Dead Rising, Saints Row, GRAW..... Etc.... I haven't even seen Oblivion push 1 mill for sales, 6 weeks and GoW sold 2 mill!!!!! thats insane for games this era with all the choices you have and even pushed Xbox Live sales 50% of where they were at. GotY should go to the game that is getting the most amount of people to sit down and play it. Oblivion has been out longer so might have some hours to GoW, but for what its done in less then 2 months, it should be a gimme for what its brought to gamers and to the next-gen in gaming.

CasSpy
CasSpy

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

CRAT0S
CRAT0S

This show is an abomination. The first picture explains it all. FIFTY CENT? WTF DOES HE HAVE TO DO WITH GAMES?? NOTHING. GET THAT WANNA BE OUT OF HERE. I mean really, this whole show is an insulting joke. It's pop culture trash, and most videogamers are counter-culture (the real ones, not the kid who bought a PS3 just to play madden). This mass-conglomerated hip hop media thing has to die. NOW. While I love Oblivion, an award from Spike doesn't really count for anything. Hopefully some orginization that actually KNOWS something about games will put together a real award show someday that has some credibility.

dtrain82
dtrain82

ok well just in response to the couple ppl that disagreed with me on the comparison to GOW to KILSWITCH. i have played both games i actually own them both and i agree with you that GOW is is a perfect game in pretty much every way but all i was saying is the its the same basic concept even if KILLSWITCH didnt do it very well, its still been done before. MERRY CHRISTMAS : )

racerx737
racerx737

I'm glad Oblivion got Game of the Year. It means that they'll hopefully come out with a Game of the Year Edition like they did with Morrowind.

tanner2000
tanner2000

Well, I knew it was going to be between GoW and Oblivion, but the victor was still unclear in my mind. I do support the choice of Oblivion though because GoW may be one of the most awesome games I've ever had the privilege to play, Oblivion took immersion in games to the next level... and then a few more levels after that. Regardless, both titles make me proud to own a 360 (yet sad that it broke, but hey, it's over a year old now [that's right, i got mine of launch day]).

adijan
adijan

UI was scrathcing my head and saying WTF?? How did oblivion beat GOW? So Yes i was a bit scratchin and i do understand why but come on!

keinuveye
keinuveye

IMO they are both fairly overrated, though Oblivion is still a masterpiece

Deathsbeast
Deathsbeast

Im just glad oblivion got what it deserved, they spent way too much work on it for it NOT to win, (although theres still plenty of bugs to be fixed...)

codyw32
codyw32

[This message was deleted at the request of a moderator or administrator]

schlarbinator
schlarbinator

Didn't Burnout Revenge win an award last year?

ParisSun
ParisSun

Stop whinning GoW fans. You won 4 awards. This has been a good year for 360. Oblivion deserved the win. It was an immersive game that allowed for many hours of game play. Gears suffered from an under developed, short single player mode. Not everyone wants to spend every waking moment online with a bunch of drolling ADD patients. I think both games are great but Oblivion offered more. Now, I can't wait till next years awards. If the upcoming games (FFXIII, MGS, H3, ME, AC, AW, etc.) even live up to half of the hype then it will be a great year.

LongShot42
LongShot42

i usually dont like these kinda things but this year they didnt do so bad i think guitar hero 2 should have won most addictive

Tyveil
Tyveil

QAAQ you should have watched the show 3 years ago when it first came out.. it was horrible. This year was actually incredibly good compared to the first.

GeeverTidus
GeeverTidus

wot!!! FFxII, Okami and KH2 ddn't get any award?!! Mmmm anyway Spike TV(VGA) is just a crappy show. look at the winners only 4 deserves the award. The gaming industry hasn't come up w/ a highly reputable gaming awards show...The hardcore gamers doesn't need these crappy V-game awards show to tell us who really deserves to be commended..

yinyang3
yinyang3

Wasn't there a best magazine of the year last year?

gamerdude27
gamerdude27

dtrain82 - "im getting pretty sick of hearing ppl say that theres nothing like GOW, come on ppl. how about you go to your basement, brush your ps2 off and turn on some KILLSWITCH. they are the same game " OK, that was pathetic. If you had actually taken the time to play GeOW (which you obviously haven't), you probably wouldn't of said what you just did. First off, Killswitch shouldn't even be mentioned in the same sentence as GeOW. It was a mediocre title at best that failed to implement true cover tactics. Gears of War is a masterpiece of a shooter that is superb in every category and is one of the most intense and exciting games in years, which you would know if you had played it. It takes shooters to the next level. Anyways, as far as the GOTY awards go, I think Oblivion deserved the prize. Even though GeOW is a stellar game, Oblivion is simply a timeless classic that will go down as one of the greatest RPG's of all-time. After logging in 200+ hours, I can confidently make that statement. Honestly, I don't think I have ever been so immersed in a game experience like I was while playing Oblivion. FFXII may be a great RPG too 'Kanoblade', but it doesn't compete on the level of Oblivion and certainly doesn't do enough new things for the franchise to make it GOTY; it should've at least been a canidate, though. I agree that this system needs to be revised.

KanoBlade
KanoBlade

You know, i usually don't write anything either dtrain82, but you've clearly haven't played GOW. Having played both, i can say they are very different, GOW definetly being the better game of the 2. Also, they always screw up the rpg category, first they choose KOTOR2 over Jade Empire and now they've chosen Oblivion over FFXII. I've played 190 hours of oblivion and loved every moment, but it's no where near as good as FFXII. These awards would be legitimate if they were judged from all of the top publication sites, then it would truly be awesome. Finally, if you're going to have Team Sports Games Awards, and the nominated games are all from the same publisher, why don't you just make it sports company or something similar, EA already sucks so stop giving them praise.

QAAQ
QAAQ

When this show first came out , I thought finally this industry will get the attention and praise it deserves. Then I saw the show...I could not watch it for more than 10 minutes. It's like watching the teen choice awards, except the format is video games. When will this be taken seriously? Who decides what titles are elgible for a catergory? who decides the winners? It should be people in the industry and prominant outside sources(ie.Gamespot,etc) It seems to me this whole show is very questionable in its autenticity and accuracy. (and come-on, Samuel L. Jackson? you really think he plays video games?.even the choice of the host is B.S.) The horror awards were much better suited for this format.

xtremeg4m3r
xtremeg4m3r

The most likely reason oblivion got best rpg because its nexgen all the way. But im sure if kh2 and ff12 woould of been next gen they would of landed best rpg

dtrain82
dtrain82

ok well i dont usually write these things but im getting pretty sick of hearing ppl say that theres nothing like GOW, come on ppl. how about you go to your basement, brush your ps2 off and turn on some KILLSWITCH. they are the same game except with GOW looking and playing better so for the ppl who keep saying GOW revolutionized gameplay go back a few yrs and check out what KILLSWITCH has done for us. thx all MERRY CHRISTMAS may you all get the games youve been wanting

Ichiziro
Ichiziro

hey, wheres best NPC? and supporting NPC? lol i would love to see one for best death... and best ending would be a good one too and something like most promising game...

edmakel
edmakel

MasterAsh42 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Partner??? what is your problem? I'm just curious??? I'm not trying to offend , but you sound like an unhappy person....

Remy_Labue
Remy_Labue

Timstuff I wish that Clover won Studio of the Year, if for no other reason than to show Capcom what a bunch of idiots they are for shutting them ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Here Here! Completely agree.

BewilderedRonin
BewilderedRonin

Someone should tell CliffyB that his little "pop and shoot" isn't all that new and revolutionary. Don't believe me? Check out a little dustbin gem called Kill Switch. It's short and the story is pretty weak and almost non-existent, but Namco did the 3rd person duck and cover shooter way before GoW did. Don't get me wrong, GoW is a great game. It's beautiful to look at and it truly is a great game and deserves all of the praise it's getting. But I'm really getting sick of people saying the "pop and shoot" game mechanic is so ground-breaking and original.

JBDragon
JBDragon

Most all games are the same as past games, just look different, play a bit different, things mixed up. But in General, Nothing is really completely NEW these days. There are a few Exceptions. Any new game out today is based on a old game in one way or another. NOTHING is truly new anymore. I'd like to play Oblivion, but I don't even have time to play Gears like I want to. They both are great games, and either one winning is just fine. They are both after all 360 games anyway.

MasterAsh42
MasterAsh42

I would like to formally apologize for my previous post's bypassing of GameSpot's censorship coding. While I wasn't aware my own selection of asterick's was insufficient, ignorance is no excuse for breaking the rules. What follows is my previous post, with a better choice of phrase in lieu of the offending one: "Get rid of the industry-inappropriate celebrities, the hip-hop, and categories belonging to film award shows, and maybe. . .I still won't watch it. "Only the cancellation of Spike TV will end this. . .The network's as big an insult to men as Lifetime is to women. In fact, all niche networks need to understanding something: the world's not so cut and dry, no matter what specific demographic to which they're catering. I can accept an over-generalization of groups of people from comedians; they're trying to make people laugh, after all. But I cannot accept this from networks, who're trying to tell me what I should like because 8 out of 10 saps polled do."