GameSpot Reviews

Player Reviews

Average Player Score Based on 399 ratings
4.1
Please Sign In to rate American Idol
Score Breakdown Based on 399 ratings
  1. 10 (49)
  2. 9 (10)
  3. 8 (16)
  4. 7 (32)
  5. 6 (16)
  6. 5 (37)
  7. 4 (35)
  8. 3 (36)
  9. 2 (42)
  10. 1 (126)

Most Helpful Critical Player Reviews

What Gamespot Users have to say about American Idol

  • User Rating:1

    You have got to be kidding me...this is a game I don't even need to play to know how much it sucks. Its amazing what game companies will turn into video games now. American Idol...what next, Joe Millionaire? Yeah, tha... Read Full Review

    5 of 6 users found the following review helpful
  • User Rating:7.5

    I only managed to play the 85 percent demo, which supposedly did not reflect the final version. The game has cel-shaded graphics that look as good as cel-shaded graphics can. If you don't like rhythym games, then t... Read Full Review

    1 of 3 users found the following review helpful
  • User Rating:1

    This is the most horrible game to ever come out. I only saw the videos and man does it suck. The judges are way to nice and never rip on you, HECK, they arn't even the voices by the real judges. They don't even have thei... Read Full Review

    0 of 1 users found the following review helpful
  • User Rating:3.6

    Have you ever been bored out of your mind???? SURE YOU HAVE!! Well, i was sooooo bored that I borrowed my step-sister's game "American Idol". Wow, what a crappy game. The graphics are horrible and so is the whole gamepla... Read Full Review

    1 of 3 users found the following review helpful
  • User Rating:10

    BEST GAME EVER!

    THE BEST GAME OF ALL TIME THE BEST GAME OF ALL TIME THE BEST GAME OF ALL TIME THE BEST GAME OF ALL TIME THE BEST GAME OF ALL TIME THE BEST GAME OF ALL TIME THE BEST GAME OF ALL TIME THE BEST GAME OF ALL TIME THE ... Read Full Review

    1 of 9 users found the following review helpful
  • User Rating:3.5

    Ummmmmmmmmm, no.

    This game bites!!!!!!!! Come on! It's a siging game but you'd think it would at least be a rip-off of Karaoke Revolution!!!!!!!!!!!! You'r pressing the buttons and your charecter sings.C'mon!!!!!!!!! And even when your ... Read Full Review

    1 of 1 users found the following review helpful
  • User Rating:1.1

    uhm.....wtf is this? this isnt a game, is it?

    This game is so totally awesome! At first, you can make your player out of 10 CHOICES. THE GREATNESS! And not just because they all look the same. Oh no. You can change the character's color to black, white, or MEXICAN! ... Read Full Review

    1 of 1 users found the following review helpful
  • User Rating:1.6

    American Idol may just be the worst game on the PS2

    Before I start let me say that I had really low expectations for this so called game but when I saw it at Walmart for ten dollars I decided to give it a chance but oh what a mistake that was.The graphics in this game are... Read Full Review

    0 of 0 users found the following review helpful
  • User Rating:1

    Worse game I've ever played ;o

    The graphics are bad, choosing outfits is a chore and the karaoke bit is dismal. There are no lyrics, just the music (so you can't drown your voice :s) and there's no progressive bars just the words written underneath a... Read Full Review

    0 of 0 users found the following review helpful
  • User Rating:1.8

    I don't like it.

    American Idol. I don't know why they made a game about it for PS2. Why don't people just watch the show? Like they have the kareyokee thingie, but i'd rather play that then this piece of crap. I think Red Steel was ba... Read Full Review

    0 of 0 users found the following review helpful
  • 23 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3