I was thrilled by the first one, but this one is not as good as the other one, though it has some philosophic concepts, like the time loop where our writer friend is caught up. Basically you have to escape this time loop and regain your wife. Mr. Scratch, your evil self, wants to take your life as well as your wife. In order to escape the Darkness he brings to this world you have to repeat thrice the same actions, better and better, to bring him down. There are, of course, manuscript pages scattered all over the world. You should read them to get the story. The enemies are too easily brought down. You have have plenty of ammunition and you have to collect as many manuscript pages as possible to unlock different weapons. Overall it's a good game, not a great one and the main drawbacks are its shortness and easiness.
Other Helpful Reviews for Alan Wake's American Nightmare
The Good: Interesting new story, fun new weapons and enemies, arcade mode is fun, still looks good The Bad: Same three areas are repeated too many times, very short, story lacks substance, new characters are uninteres... Read Full Review
Alan Wake's American Nightmare takes place after the original game. You are in Arizona and need to defeat Mr. Grinch, who is in fact your double. He uses your identity to be you in the real life. He has both your life, a... Read Full Review